23 December 2007

Speaking of PC and the 'War on Christmas'

It just makes me shake my head

PC or not, have a Merry Christmas

In the US these days, you can get in trouble for saying "Merry Christmas". Politically correct do-gooders argue that it marginalises people of other faiths, to whom December 25 is just the day after December 24.

Complaints from these allegedly marginalised people are conspicuous by their scarcity and we rather fancy that their faith is robust enough to withstand the implied challenge. In any event, opinion polls suggest that the pendulum is swinging back: two out of three Americans prefer the old-fashioned greeting. And at least some of the rest must think that "Bah, humbug!" captures the flavour of the season.

Having taken all this into account, we have decided to wish you a "Merry Christmas" anyway, but we stress that we mean it in an inclusive, non-marginalising way. If you want to translate it into terms more meaningful to you, go ahead.

Whatever the next few days means to you, it's important to recognise that the family over the fence may read it differently. And, whether you regard it as a religious or secular festival, it's a good time of year to think about others.

Christmas means family get-togethers, which many of us regard with a mixture of delight and horror. So do your bit: smile graciously as you open relatives' tasteless gifts or do the dishes as they snore on the couch. Spare a thought, and a dollar or two, for the less fortunate and the social and voluntary agencies who are looking after their needs. And remember when you're on the road, at the beach and in the bush: you're sharing it with everyone else and there's enough to go around. Take care of each other out there.


I'm not entirely sure why an editorial that ends on such a thoughtful note has to begin with such, well, stupidity. Clearly the editors have been spending too much time watching Fox News and the second graph makes the same mistake most wingnuts make on a regular basis--'I haven't seen it (not that I bothered to actually look for it) so it must not exist.' And what is this 'pendulum is swinging back' crap? Back from what? Was there *ever* a time when people who said 'Merry Christmas' were in the minority or even noticeably less than they are today?

Of course, getting on the Christmas high horse (or is it high reindeer?) is rather ridiculous in a country where fewer than 1-in-10 people attend church weekly, one of the lowest rates in the industrialized world. Perhaps by 'Merry Christmas' they really mean 'don't get trampled at the mall.'

2 Comments:

Blogger jamielio said...

The whole War on Christmas thing drives me insane. Every year at my various family Xmas gatherings (which are, of course wholly based on materialism - er, secularism), someone starts the rant about how "Nope, can't say 'Merry Christmas' anymore, wouldn't want to offend anyone! Gotta say 'Happy Holidays,' so those PC liberals don't get upset!" I used to try to fight back, but now I just bury my face in my cup of eggnog. Ugh.

Sunday, 23 December, 2007  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

You should just say "merry holiday based on the pagan winter solstice tried to change to a "Christian" holiday by the people that bought you the Spanish inquisition, not even close to the actual day Christ was born, now turned into a commercialized sport of getting as much crap as cheap as you can Day"... but that may be too much of a mouthful

just my .02

Monday, 24 December, 2007  

Post a Comment

<< Home